Beyond Meat's Ethan Brown: How to teach your customer

The very best founders I know are brilliant at building systems. They connect teams, they remove bottlenecks, and they eliminate single points of failure. And yet When it comes to their own wealth. Most are running a disconnected stack. A tax accountant here and a state attorney there, a wealth manager who doesn't talk to either one of them.

Creative planning was built to fix exactly that. One integrated team of tax professionals, state planners, investment specialists, all coordinated by a dedicated wealth manager who sees your full financial picture and keeps every piece working together. Proactive tax efficiency, state strategy, investments all under one roof. Creative planning where wealth works together. Learn more at creative planning dot com slash masters of scale.

Global hiring is such a headache when you're building fast, but companies like Eleven Labs are scaling effortlessly with deal. They quadrupled their workforce in twenty twenty five. Without hiring an HR team. Build your global team with deal. Visit deal.com slash MOS and start expanding your business today. That's D E L

dot com. Slash M O S. Hey, folks, Jeff Berman here. I am thrilled to share some of the new names who will be joining us at this year's Masters of Scale summit. This may be our biggest stage yet. Reed Hastings, Meredith Whitaker, Van Jones, Amjad Masad, and more.

Will be there with us October 20th through 22nd in San Francisco. If you're building something great, or you want to build something great, We want you there with us too. Join us at masters of scale dot com slash apply twenty six. That's mastersofscot com slash apply. Twenty six.

I was actually at a restaurant called Crossroads with Jay-Z. This was some years ago. I was like, what is this? What what in the world is this? So then Fast forward to me playing in Houston.

I got a chance to try plant based meat. That is Superstar Point Guard Chris Paul. He's been in the NBA since two thousand and five. Since then, he's been rookie of the year. NVP of the All Star Game.

He's won two Olympic gold medals. And in 2019, Chris started eating plant based. You know, in sports people always say that Your gut is your second brain.

And it it's real. It is real. Just like anybody, I had dairy, had meat, everything my whole life. We play these games and After games you eat.

And a lot of times you eat and you just like, ugh. Like you slumped over. This was enough. for Chris to start shifting just a little away from full carnivore. Well, I done played a lot of games in these last sixteen years of my career.

And after games, I wake up and I'm sore. Aqui. I've had a number of surgeries. And I was like, hold on. They're saying that.

You perform better. You have more energy. Are they lying? Is this a trick? And so I literally

Went cold turkey. Or what people say, they say cold tofu. Alright, I want cold tofu. came back from a family vacation. And on a Monday, I stopped eating meat.

But then, as Chris tells it. the payoff started kicking in. I called my trainer and I was like are we not Lifting heavy, are we not working out hard? Бикасо

All that stuff that I felt for years. It went away. Today Chris will talk veganism with anyone who will listen, including you.

But as a professional athlete, no decision he makes is in a vacuum. It was critical that Chris convince his wider team. That includes every single trainer and coach whose livelihood depends on his success. My trainer was like, What are you doing this for? Why, you know, everybody always said that you gonna lose so much weight, you gonna get so small, you

Gotta make sure you check your blood, make sure you get B12. My chef, my team, my trainers. People were very cautious. Alright, we play a lot of games. I've been playing for a lot of years and they like if it's not broke. Don't fix it.

But to me, it actually was kind of broke. What Chris was trying to do isn't easy. He was asking his trainers and coaches, people who have spent their lives telling other people how to eat. to adopt a totally new mindset. which meant considering a possibility that what they knew was wrong.

Most entrepreneurs face this same challenge when bringing a new product or idea to the market. And most customers, just like Chris's coaches, take a little convincing. But unlike those coaches. There's rarely a contract. To keep a customer at your side.

If you violate their wishes. They can just walk away. Even if deep down. You know you're right. That's why I believe that you need to listen to your customers.

Even when what they want is inconvenient. Or inconsistent or even wrong. Track their point of view. And let them know you're listening. You gotta have incredible talent at every position.

Huge push. There are fires burning when you're going out. Can you believe it? Such an idiot. And then you go back to this is totally gonna be amazing. There are so many easy ways. So I have no idea what to do. Sorry, we made a mistake. But you have to time it right. Oops. Working out of a three-bedroom apartment. Just how you do it. This His master's of scale. I'm Reed Hoffman, co-founder of LinkedIn, partner at Greylock.

And your host. And I believe you need to listen to your customers. Even when what they want is inconvenient, inconsistent, or even wrong. You don't need to agree. But you must track their point of view.

and let them know you're listening. When you're trying to scale, I like to say Bits are easier than atoms. Which just means that software is easier to scale than goods in the physical world. Easier to test, easier to launch.

And easier to get fast feedback on every aspect to your product. From I'm having trouble using it. Two I want this button to be purple.

You want to try and create that feedback loop for every product or service you offer. Because customer tastes can be idiosyncratic and unpredictable. You can plan for every use case, every preference, and never come up with I want the button to be purple.

The work it takes to change a button from red to purple might be negligible in the digital world. So you do it. Issue a global update and it's done. But this change. Can be crushingly expensive with a physical product.

Think about all the millions of widgets with red buttons you'd need to recall. And you know in your heart of hearts. It makes absolutely no difference to your product. What color the button is. So what do you do?

Do you still change the button? I wanted to talk to Ethan Brown about this because no one has spent more time obsessing over the balance between what makes the best product and what the customer actually wants. Even when those aren't the same. As the founder and CEO of Beyond Meet. Ethan has spent his career on a wildly difficult challenge.

creating a new category of food that people actually trust. We're very conservative. As a species when it comes to what we want to put in our mouth. For good reason'cause it can die if you put the wrong thing in. There's a scepticism that you have to overcome.

Ethan grew up with a healthy sense of skepticism himself. Splitting his time between urban life and And life on the farm. I grew up in the city, but there was this farm we bought very early in my life in the western part of the state of Maryland. And it's up up really high on the mountain there and just a beautiful place. And I fell in love with not only the animals in the fields and streams and forests.

But also became very interested in the ones in the barn. I was never given the answer as to why animals in the barn had a different fate than animals inside our house. And so I was sort of left to figure that out. Let's say a pig and a dog They were clearly different beings.

But I had trouble understanding why one was treated one way and the other another way. was pretty incoherent about how I approached things. I tried and I struggled. Should I just eat fish? Should I just eat humanely raised animals? You know, there's a while where I wasn't eating any meat but I was wearing leather. Natural college, I became vegetarian, then ultimately vegan.

And it was that integration of if I care enough to be vegetarian, then I should probably care enough to be vegan. If I care enough to be vegan, then I should probably also think about the clothes I wear and everything else. Not only was it hard to develop a consistent ideology, But it was hard to get others to understand it. Even before he'd gone full vegan. In college I played basketball, but I kept getting injured and people would say

because you don't eat meat. And I didn't have the nutritional understanding to know how false that was. That sounds a lot like Chris Paul's story at the top of the episode. Ethan was fighting the cultural bias that meat is what makes you strong. The thing is That bias didn't come out of nowhere.

Early humans made evolutionary leaps and bounds once we learned how to hunt. And again. when we learned how to cook what we hunted. Meat did, in a real evolutionary sense, make us strong. But since then

Humans have also learned how to get complete protein from plants. Some types of meat substitutes are over 2,000 years old. Yet. Most of us still have this gut level instinct that meat is still king. It's less.

That it's wrong. And more. That it used to be right. As Ethan graduated college, He turned his attention not to food production, but to another industry that's environmentally focused.

How did you get into energy? So when I was just out of school, I was actually having conversation with my dad about this. We're sitting in his office And I said, I'm just not sure what I want to do. I'm having trouble deciding. And

He asked me, he said sort of what's the biggest problem in the world? I think in a very literal sense, like what is the biggest problem? You can be a great surgeon or a great musician or actor or writer, et cetera, but if the world has become destabilized because of climate None of those crafts can be protected. And so I thought, well, the biggest problem really is stabilizing the climate. As a systems thinker.

I appreciate this holistic approach. You may have heard me say something similar when it comes to stabilizing our democracy. Evan took his father's advice and went about tackling the world's biggest problem. He pursued a master in public policy. Focusing on the environment.

And then got to work on zero emission hydrogen fuel cell technologies. I was very interested in The equitable. consumption of carbon. How do we deal with this problem, given that most of it was from the Northern hemisphere and from developed nations, and yet the developing nations are the one that we have to curb and control If we're gonna solve this.

Ethan saw that moving the needle on energy use needed to rely on not just science, but also on tracking and responding. If industrialized nations are dumping too much carbon into the atmosphere, there are only a limited number of ways to change it. You can try and convince people to cut way way down on activities that warm the planet. Like flying or driving.

Or You can build technology that make those activities less harmful. Ethan. Went with the ladder. I still root for the technology. I love working in that sector.

But the longer he worked in the sector, the more he started noticing a different kind of customer behavior that flew in the face of science. And it was coming from within his own industry. I spent so much time with the Department of Energy and other places all the money we're spending on lithium ion batteries and these conferences I go to and then people would eat steak. That's right.

In rooms full of people who care deeply about saving the planet. They were completely ignoring one of the biggest drivers of climate change. For perspective. One serving of beef. produces twenty four times the greenhouse gases of one serving of tofu.

To Ethan, ignoring the food sector was like trying to fix a pipe that's gushing water. But refusing to use your wrench. Not only do I care passionate about this issue, but I'm focusing on a secondary solution, when it's a primary one, which is The energy we put in our bodies, not necessarily the energy we put in our cars. I had a great career. It took a lot to nudge me out of that comfort.

But it was discomfort that led me to it. I was in so much discomfort about not addressing it that I ultimately had to address it. In two thousand nine, Ethan quit his day job and founded Beyond Meat. I love this writer, Steven Johnson, who writes about the slow hunch. We love these stories of the apple falling from the tree and things like that. But they're generally not true.

you have to sit and marinate in the problem for a long time. And I had spent a decade or so marinating in this problem trying to figure out I love meat growing up. I love KFC and McDonalds and all those places and wanted to keep eating there and I had no interest in a meat substitute, like never did. I wanted to try to scientifically rebuild meat. I just want to point out This goal Ethan set.

had an impressive degree of difficulty. Not just scientifically rebuilding meat. But the ultimate goal, which was to convince meaters to change their preference to plants. Setting out to change any kind of consumer preference is not easy to do. Especially

Where food is concerned. But it was essential to his mission. He wasn't gonna solve the biggest problem in the world. By appealing just to vegetarians and vegans. To make a real dent.

He'd have to go after meat eaters. So what do you do? When your vegan product needs meet eating customers. Make it taste.

Just like meat. Now here, Ethan might quibble with my word choice. Because as he puts it. Beyond isn't just like meat. It is meat.

We'll have Ethan explain. People think meat is some kind of mystery, but in fact all the pieces you need to build a piece of meat. are already there in plants. You just gotta go find. And I know the composition is amino acids, lipids, trace minerals, vitamins, and water, and I know those are all available in plants. Then it's a question of

What is the process for getting it to form into the structure of meat without using a biological living organism? The question had become Ethan's passion. He eventually found his answer in a team of scientists at the University of Missouri. I called up a guy named Fu Hong She talked to him and his partner. Uh his partner's Harold Huff. They're both dear friends of mine today. And they were scientists who needed an entrepreneur and I was a entrepreneur needed scientists.

And we got together and man, it was a great relationship from the beginning. Doctor Shay and Mr Huff held the patent on a plant based protein that pulled apart like real chicken. It was exactly what Ethan and his brand new company were looking for. He helped the team secure funding and a new partnership was born. I had a program that I put together with the University of Maryland and the University of Missouri.

And got grants from the state, uh, Maryland to do that. You know, I've said this before that big companies have R and D budgets and entrepreneurs have universities. You know, I just am absolutely convinced that We are leaving so much on the table by not just mining these universities for the great research they're doing. So I began to put those two programs together and started to work on not necessarily a product, but a structure. And it was a muscle structure. fell in love with this structure of being able to tear it apart and see the muscle fiber. It was that striation of muscle

We take the protein from a plant, we take the lipids from a plant, we take the minerals from non-animal sources. Combine those with water and vitamins. Run that through heating, cooling, and pressure. to structure them into the architecture of muscle. Meat. This was the Eureka moment that would make everything else possible.

A plant based structure that not just tasted like meat, but but ripped apart like meat. This was what Ethan was looking for. There was just one problem. The best product if you want to go out in the market would be beef, because that's the thing that people always understand.

is most deleterious to their body and all the issues that we know about. But this particular system lent itself not to what was best for the market. This lent itself to chicken. Here we come to an interesting dilemma.

One that many entrepreneurs will recognize. The plant based meat they'd made wasn't the so called fake meat that They knew the public would be hungriest for. If replacing burgers or steak is what the public really wants, is it worth going to market with a substitute for chicken? Ethan decided.

Yes. I said, okay, so in that way we kinda let technology lead us. So we launched with this chicken product as really the first real product that we had. We actually always knew that beef was the better play. I just didn't have a technological solution for it. So does this mean Ethan ignored the customers' wishes?

No. Because he was solving for an even more basic customer demand. That it tastes. Just like the real thing. The market was already full of meat substitutes meant to placate that vegetarian friend at a barbecue.

If Beyond was going to get lift off, their first product. had to taste so much like meat. It would seem like magic. Their target customer. was their biggest skeptic.

Not just the meat eater. But the meat lover. Ethan understood that point of view all too well. From his own pre vegan days. Nobody likes a piece of fried chicken more than me. I love that stuff.

And I really look forward to eating it. Right. And that's why we're working so hard on this. That's a good experience to have. Let's keep giving people the opportunity to have it. Let's do it with plants. The brander in me, the brand marketer in me, would have been tempted to create a new word, as opposed to calling it meat.

You know, call it something else. Yeah. But I think you guys must have had that discussion and decided not to because you wanted to say, No, this is meat. Yes. Yeah. Man, I mean, we've debated that forever, including how we spelled meat and all these things. And Biz was a big part of that. Bistone. Co-founder of Twitter Early investor and Beyond Meat.

It's not wanting to be a side show. Not wanting to be you can have chicken, beef, or pork, or you can have this. Ethan knew that this distinction would be the key to mass adoption. He was betting his company on it. Early on we tried to get our chicken into the meat case.

they've arranged a call with a time CEO of Whole Foods Walter Rob. Uh co CO. And they weren't ready, we weren't ready. Didn't happen. This was a blow to beyond meat strategy.

If their target customer is a meet eater. They would need to find them where that customer shops. in the meat aisle. But getting into the meat case wasn't Beyonds only play. If they couldn't do that.

they could continue to improve their product. And they could work on their plant based beef. Which? If you remember, is what they knew their customers would want most. It was almost a race.

To see which product, chicken or beef. Would finally convince the Walter Robs of the world to stalk beyond with the other meat. This race would come to a head in 2013 when they got the opportunity to bring in a very important taste tester. That could make? Or break the company.

When you build substantial wealth through your business, it's often tied up in a single equity position. The upside is real, but so is the risk, and knowing when to act isn't always obvious. Creative planning works with business owners to build a strategy around concentrated equity. When to diversify, how to manage tax risk, and how to protect what you've spent years building. Creative planning where wealth works together.

Learn more at creative plating dot com slash masters of scale. Oh Humans will never be more intelligent than AI. There can be two types of companies. Those were great at AI and those that went out of business because they weren't. How do we build a future?

That is human centered. I'm Rana El Chayubi. On my podcast Pioneers of AI, we answer that question and so many more. As an AI scientist, entrepreneur, and investor, I know what it takes to build AI that works for everyone. Every week, I sit down with the pioneers shaping our future. And we take you behind the scenes of the AI that's transforming our lives. Find pioneers of AI wherever you tune in.

Hey listeners, Bob here. If you listen to Rapid Response on Masters of Scale, you may be missing half the show. Because every Friday we release a second rapid response exclusively in the Rapid Response feed. The guests and topics are just as compelling and timely from Ford CEO to NASA's administrator to the lessons from The Devil Wears Prada. It takes about 10 seconds to find, just search rapid response wherever you listen to podcasts and hit follow to make sure you never miss an episode. I hope to see you there. We're back.

With Ethan Brown of Beyond Meet. And we're talking about how to understand and track customer wishes. Even when those wishes are inconvenient. Inconsistent. Or even wrong.

When we left off, Ethan and his team of scientists and food engineers were racing to get their plant-based beef burger customer ready. They already had a great plant based chicken. But they knew that their customers would want beef most of all. But In the middle of that race, they got the chance to get their first product.

The chicken in front of a very special audience. Of one. One of the things that struck me when I was reading this transition is part of your origin was actually, in fact, persuading Bill Gates by sampling with a chicken tacos. So you were you were moving away from the product. By which you persuaded Bill to get on board with the mission and invest. So tell me a little bit about your Bill Gates chicken taco experience and then you know, how that evolved in talking with him.

It was a really funny day for me. I literally couldn't get into my hotel room because I had maxed out all my cards and everything and had to run. I remember I was running at night, very late at night,'cause I wanted to get to bed and solve this issue. to try to find an ATM that would allow me to basically validate another card that I could then go use. As an entrepreneur, you may be listening right now and cringing in recognition. When you get the chance to aud in front of a potential investor like Bill Gates, you have to be ready to literally go for broke.

But the challenges. Didn't stop there. The next day where we're presenting there was not a kitchen, so we had to get an extended stay room. And I had a a brilliant chef with me, David Anderson and a bunch of our scientists and stuff, until we rented out this room and started preparing the meals for him. And David looks a little bit like he could be in a rock band.

And smoke just starts bellowing out of the room. It looks like a meth I mean it looks like something really bad is happening inside, you know. And so anyway, so He cooks an amazing meal. We rush it over there. And as we're getting to the room. To see Bill.

Three guys come out. In suits, and I wasn't wearing a suit. all rumpled looking and very dejected. And this comported completely with my anticipation because I had been told that he's gonna zero in on some numbers in your presentation and you're gonna have to do some very quick math and mental gymnastics. And you know it's gonna be a very harrowing experience. This was a live or die moment. Everything's on the line.

Ethan could have done everything right up until this point. But if this one customer didn't like his product. He might as well go home. Bill couldn't have been nicer. Couldn't have been nicer.

Just wanted to talk about the mission, about the underlying fundamentals of the business. about his children, about the world. And I've met with him a few times since and worked very closely with his fund and guy is a prince. So it was a wonderful experience. Okay, full disclosure. Knowing Bill, this does not surprise me.

Bill remembers what it's like to be an entrepreneur. Building from the ground up. And Bill has been on a mission to curb climate change for the better part of his philanthropic career. Even

If you thought the product sucked. I have no doubt. He would still be rooting for Ethan. He just wouldn't invest. It might be just

Good luck with the next pitch. Keep going. Sorry your product's terrible. And then Ethan would be totally free to pitch it somewhere else. Luckily. That's not at all what happened.

After the slightly smoke filled audition. Bill Gates wrote in his blog. No. Like most people, I don't think I can be easily fooled. But that's just what happened when I was asked to taste a chicken taco and tell whether the meat inside was real or fake.

The meat certainly had the look and smell of chicken. I took a bite and it had the taste and texture of real chicken too. But I was surprised to learn that there wasn't an ounce of real chicken in it. The meat was made entirely of plants.

And yet I couldn't tell the difference. What I was experiencing was more than a clever meat substitute. It was a taste of the future of food. So that's it, right? The end.

Go to credits. I'm Reed Hoffman. Thanks for listening. Masters of Scale is a white water original. Not exactly.

When the chicken hit the market. It wasn't a breakout hit. A New York Times food columnist called it. Bland, unexciting, and not very chicken like. But not offensive either.

And a Huffington postwriter said. The chicken strips seem to inhabit a strange territory between meat and And vegetable. These reviews weren't all bad. They did point out how close Beyond Me was to.

quote unquote. Real meat. But these also weren't the rave reviews that would launch them to scale. beyond needed to get it absolutely right on their next big product launch. The burger.

It actually went back to technology. I know the whole debate about don't let engineers run your company, listen to the customer I listen to the customer like nobody else, but I began to see that we could produce a beef that was different and important. And it wasn't until that point that I really started to invest in getting us to market. Beyond kept pushing the science until it could catch up with our market goals.

To Ethan, the race was about more than the survival of Beyond Meat. It was about The survival of the planet. I wanted to do something that was unique and extraordinary. And that's really our always our mandate to our research team.

There's a lot of people doing this, but we have set up this Manhattan Beach project here. It's supposed to evoke that sense of urgency of the Manhattan Project Second World War. You've got all these Really talented people here. Don't produce something common. produce something outrageously great. Finally.

Right around 2015 and 2016, Ethan's Manhattan Beach Project. Had a breakthrough. The breakthrough for us was being able to produce a fresh platform, something we call fresh, which is something that would appear to the human sensory experience as raw meat. Right. That was the thing. So how do we Produce something that looks like raw meat.

the transition under three or four minutes into a cook state that gives all the aroma and everything else and Gotta start to see that we could do. Remember, Ethan knew that a viable beef replacement would truly change diets and lives. But would only work if it pleased the meat eaters. And the meat eaters would only find them if their product was sitting in their usual freezer at the grocery store.

So we didn't want to put it in that penalty box of the meat alternative section. Always wanted it to be in the meat case. So we finally Add a product worthy of doing that. And in twenty fifteen or sixteen we got in there. This. was the birth of the beyond burger. And its appearance.

Changed everything. It bled like a real beef burger. It sizzled on the grill. It looked raw. Was the theory of being in the meat section that

Actually, in fact, to meet the mission, people have to understand that this is Literally just at least as good and interesting and be there versus the penalty box or Was it that that's the only way the transformation's gonna happen? Or what was the theory of we must be in that same place? It was we want to be on the main stage in the most basic sense of the proposition. But more nuanced than that was the desire to

be part of and almost celebrate all the trappings of meat. And so to not run counter to what people love so much about meat, but rather create something that's better. Putting beyond meat where other meat lived was in a way. Telling customer, not just We're in the right place.

But You're in the right place. There's a distinct boldness in this approach. Rather than scold a customer for not shopping in the vegan aisle, It's saying

You're not wrong to love meat. We love me too. Now try ours. But getting in front of their target customer wasn't Beyond Meet's only challenge. They also had to get that customer to reject some longstanding.

Deeply held. and frankly wrong beliefs about plants. That's where folks like Chris Paul come in. So let's talk a little bit about marketing, talk a little bit about your talent acquisition and deployment as part of that. And how like hey, this is meat.

This is actually in fact the same thing and matter of fact, better for you, better for the world, better for All kinds of things. So talk a little bit about that. As I mentioned, I had this exposure as a kid to agriculture and we had a dairy farm. We had a hundred head of whole steam cattle. So I paid attention to the milk industry a lot. And then I loved athletics and so the milk does a body good was the first campaign and then the milk mustache campaign and got milk.

I just remember being surprised, alarmed, curious, interested in the fact that you could advertise a particular type of protein in schools directly to kids. You know, like I didn't see Huffy Bikes being able to do that. Like it was just how'd they get that? When it came time for us to build a marketing campaign, I actually called the original sponsor of the Got Milk campaign.

For those of you who didn't grow up in the US in a specific period of the 90s, the Got Milk Campaign. Featured athletes, actors, and all manners of celebrities posing with a glass of cow juice and sporting a thickly applied milk mustache. The message. Milk makes you stronger, healthier, and more agile. You know.

Like athletes are. It was the author of this epic campaign that Ethan wanted for Beyond Meat. This guy Jeff Manning, who's a dear friend now. I say, Can you help me create a program where I can help them understand that if they consume this product, they're gonna look and feel better and have a better long term health outcome. And so there's controversy around milk, but there should not be controversy around this because the science is so clear. With Jeff's help.

And the help of a bunch of smart players on Beyond's marketing team, they crafted campaigns around celebrity endorsements. Everyone from Snoop Dogg. And Shaquille O'Neal to Sean White and Lindsey Vaughn. They especially leaned into athletes as the ideal spokespeople for their product. Like Chris Paul.

Chris Paul is a great example. Chris, thirty six years old. Been in the NBA for a very long time. Caught an alley of dunk during the twenty twenty all star game. After the game they ask him, How are you doing that at your age? He's six foot.

Maybe six one. Well I went plant based. I don't have any more inflammation. I don't even have to ice anymore. That's one of Ethan's favorite stories, cause Ethan act like I can't dunk. Once again, NBA All Star Chris Paul.

I actually dunk pretty often now. And it's been a combination of changing my trainers and changing my diet. I don't want to say diet. I hate that word because diet to me sounds temporary. You know, it has to be A lifestyle change. Since becoming vegan.

Chris says he's really felt a difference in his postgame routine. Uh Three games in the last five, six days. I don't have to ice my knees after games. That's so crazy to me. Right.

I played a game last night, didn't ice after the game. And I'm up walking around Like it's nothing. And you can't tell me that that's not directly correlated to being plant based because I played so many years and so many games And I've woke up those next days after games like aching.

Sore and can't move and It's nice. It's definitely made basketball better, but more than anything, it's made life more enjoyable. Playing with my kids. It sounds crazy, but it If I had a game on a Wednesday for years and my kids wanted to go in the back yard and like

play baseball or do something on a Tuesday afternoon, I'd be like, you know, Dad gotta sit. I gotta rest. I gotta rest my legs. You know, I gotta do this, but No, life is so much better now. This kind of testimony is exactly what Ethan was hoping for. You can hear the sincerity. In Chris's story.

And see the proof in the game tape. Edwin Land, who I really admire, the inventor of the Polaroid. had a funny line, which is not really true, but he says, you know, marketing is what you do when your product's no good. And you do have to market because there's so many differentiated products in the market. Or you have to differentiate rather, but If there's truth to what you're doing, it's a hell of a lot easier to market. And so having these athletes out there doing that is incredible.

Using Chris and other trusted ambassadors helped ease the customer into a more open mindset. A mindset. that would accept this brand new product as not just as good as meat. but indistinguishable from need itself. I mentioned before.

Just how hard it is to create an entirely new food category. that people will feel okay about. Much less. Turn into obsessive fans. Ethan knew that already.

as he had pointed out earlier in the show. We're very conservative. species when it comes to what we want to put in our mouth. For good reason,'cause it can die if you put the wrong thing in, but There's a skepticism that you have to overcome.

Ethan and his team worked incredibly hard to overcome that skepticism. He personally drove. From supermarket to supermarket, giving samples and interacting with customers. I would drive around and Maryland and Ohio, Kentucky, Pennsylvania.

Meet with these clients and meet with chefs all over the place too. go to universities and try to sell into their hospitals, stuff like that. And that's the thing about when you build a business and you don't have venture fund in the beginning, the customer is your lifeline, the consumer is your lifeline. And so I listened to the customer all day long when I was building this business in the stores, giving out samples and stuff like that. And so I knew what their reservations were and one of them was is there anything artificial in it?

Is this real? This concern about what was real was one that Ethan completely understood. But the answer was a little bit more complicated than yes or no. The concept is it real? was an interesting one. Right. And so yes, it is a real assembly of the core parts of meat.

It didn't run through an animal. And that was the complicated part to explain and still is. That's the thing we really have to keep marketing on is People say it's processed and then you say well it's a tail of two processes, right? This is our process. Ethan's already told us a bit about this process. We take the protein from a plant, we take the lipids from a plant, we take the minerals from non-animal sources.

Combine those with water and vitamins. run that through heating, cooling, and pressure. to structure them into the architecture of muscle. Neat. Yeah.

You feed those plants and you give that water to the animal. And then they develop that muscle, that animal is then subject to the antibiotics, to the slaughter, and then that is present on the center of your plate. Both are real assemblies. One comes from one source and one comes from the other. And we have to make that really clear to people. That's what we're working on.

We got to thinking, how could you make this tale of two processes even clearer? So In classic masters of scale fashion, we came up with a handy song that might help. If you want to disrupt the meat basinery, don't you look any further than your market greenery Starts with science, Baba, beans and peas The process is plant-based, the product is meat The structure that makes your burger complete Only comes from plants and leaves, Bessie and E's You take the protein and the fats from vegetation Vegan minerals and vitamins into the congregation

Golden Breast. The tissue structure is addressed, the meat assembly, it isn't fallacy, the work is not just a show, it's also Najee about you to the core Just like the snakes at the store, the work of R and D you get the color using Send the head to chemistry director Works on smell and taste with an E nose aroma inspector The vegetable process is inside

Oh. Truth unconcealed. This process is real. Even didn't have our handy song when he was taking his product samples around to supermarkets.

Rather, what he had were hundreds of one on one conversations with customers. After the question of whether beyond meat. Was natural or real. It was another question he got all the time. So does this burger like have GMOs?

GMOs Genetically modified organisms Answering this question right. would prove critical to beyond meat's success.

There's a skepticism that you have to overcome. That's one of the reasons I stay away from GMOs. It's just too controversial. And whatever my own views are don't really matter. Biologists in our audience already know that GMO is a very, very broad term. You could say that technically Every ear of corn we eat has been genetically modified from ancient maize.

But that doesn't change the wall. Of negative customer opinion that Ethan would have to face if he used plants that had been genetically modified. In the modern sense. This is the parallel of the purple button from the beginning of the episode. Is it a pain to avoid GMOs altogether when making food products?

Kind of. Is it important to the customer? Extremely. So You listen.

Another strong customer preference Ethan followed despite the science. Made his work a little trickier. And that was around whether to use soy in the Beyond Burger. Historically.

Soy has been one of the most popular sources of plant protein in the world. It's the building block of tofu. Veganism's long suffering workhorse. And if your mandate is making plant based protein.

it's genuinely difficult to leave it out. But Ethan had been listening intently to customer feedback. The time we were coming into market in 2009 and 10 and 11, soy was being demonized. I have no issue with soy whatsoever. I drink a ton of soy milk. I think it's a great whole high amino acid score, really, really good crop and product. But

I'm not gonna use it because I know the consumer doesn't want it. So was the shift from soy entirely customer demand? Yeah, in fact we knew it wasn't right. We knew that the consumer of sediment on it was wrong. The issue came down to something called phytoestrogen. A type of plant hormone that occurs naturally in soybeans.

We have a great program with Stanford their medical school because one of our scientists had worked in the labs over there working on treating cancer, and they had tried to use phytoestrogen from soy To see if it had any effect on the body. And it just passed through and had no effect. This seems like a pretty groundbreaking discovery. One, that you might even want to shout.

From the rafters. This just in. Stanford scientists give the all clear to soy. Across the land, relieved diners dig into plates of Ebame. Our long national nightmare finally over. But Ethan had seen and heard from enough customers to know what decisions might break their fragile trust.

And honoring that trust. Was more important. than picking this particular battle. Ultimately. This wasn't about any one ingredient.

It was about an ethos. on which Beyond and their customers are totally aligned. They just want it to be natural. People want to eat like their grandparents ate. They just want to do it in a healthier manner. Ethan has continued to listen obsessively to the customer, including when it came time to IPO in two thousand nineteen. I think in twenty thirteen I set a goal to IPO and we our revenue was so

Small, it was a joke that I was doing it, but you don't think it at the time. You think, Oh, it's totally reasonable. Like five year plan, blah blah blah. I think we missed it by a year, but it wasn't so much for the capital because we had great funders. For me, it was for the marketing and the ability to open up to the public who so loved this brand and what we're doing and help us build it, the opportunity to become shareholders. you know, for so many years we're being asked can we buy shares by individuals and I think this company has been built by the consumer. We've certainly listened to them and I wanted them to be part of it.

Beyond meat. has worked hard to keep their finger on the consumer pulse during the pandemic. We pivoted extremely quickly. to retail. So we started to

Take all of our food service products that could be packaged into retail and packed them in retail. And we launched a very low cost offering called the Cookout Classic, which was 10 burgers for$1.60 a burger or something, which is much cheaper than where we were. We did that. Almost overnight. At the time the beef industry was undergoing a lot of supply shock, so their prices were spiking.

And so we did this as an opportunity to get closer to the price of beef at a time when people needed value. And so we just tried to capitalize to the extent we could on changing market conditions. get as much of our inventory out of the food service space and into retail and it worked. Well didn't go as smoothly was

It was a year of variability. In the sense that the consumer Would. go into source and stock up like crazy and then not go back. And when that's happening in real time

You're not exactly sure what's happening. This was a problem. Ethan's key to success has been consistently Paying attention to customer habits. So in that portion of the pandemic.

When customers were cleaning entire supermarket shell, it was really hard to track what they were going for. You're not sure if they've shifted over completely to retail for the long term? Right. or where they're coming and going. And they were kind of coming and going. And so when you have a network that needs to have steady supply. That gets really hard to manage. And that was a challenge for us.

Yep. This is one of the Adams things, the supply chains and inventory, transport, the whole thing. Much harder in your business than most of the businesses I do. And so respect. Thank you. I appreciate that. Oh, it means a lot. Thank you. Thank you. We might end Ethan's story there.

Except. That something happened that would prove to be a much more newsworthy ending. Beyond Me announced three massive new multi-year partnerships with PepsiCo, McDonald's and Yum Brands. Each collaboration will yield new plant based products.

Including at McDonald's, something called McClant Burger. Edit Yum. Making menu items for KFC. Pizza Hut and Taco Bell.

Their PepsiCo joint venture is called The Planet. Partnership. capitalized in a way to highlight the word plant. After all. You can't have one without the other.

These partnerships are exactly how you get to widespread adoption and massive scale. It's the goal Ethan had set his sights on when he first founded the company. If there's a global crisis You don't fix it. By nibbling around its edges.

You have to take a bite. Right out of the middle. It's hard every time we have a new product. It is really hard. I spoke at Tesla a couple of years ago and I said I was really happy to be here because you guys are the only people that are worse at commercial station than we are. You know, and they just like the room just exploded because they know how hard it is. Ultimately. The dream is not having to choose between what makes a great product

And what the customer wants. In a perfect world, the two are totally aligned. But when there is conflict. Approach each one with the same question in mind. What part of this relationship can I least afford to break?

The answer. will almost always come down to customer trust. They need to trust. that you were bringing them a well built product. Backed by science.

And They need to trust. That you're listening to their concerns. That trust. is what you must preserve at all costs.

So choose your battles well. I'm Reed Hoffman. Thanks for listening. Masters of Scale is a Wakewater original. The show is recorded remotely with sanitized audio gear. Our executive producers are June Cohen and Darren Treff.

Our supervising producer is Jay Punjabi. Our producers are Jordan McCloud, Adam Skuse. Catherine Clark Ray, Halle Bonie. Marie McCoy Thompson Christina Gonzalez and Chris McCloud.

Our editor at large is Bob Sapian. Our music director is Ryan Holliday. Original music and sound design by Daniel Nissenbaum. Audio editing by Keith J. Nelson. Steven Davies and Andrew Knollt.

Mixing and Mastering by Brian Pugh. Special thanks. Chris Shay, Elisa Schreiber, David Sanford. Adam Heiner.

Emily McManus. Kelsey Capitano Kim Cronin. Sarah Sandman. Carry Goldstein.

And a pisano. Mina Korosawa. Charlie Menesis and Colin Howarth.

What you see above is a preview of the first minutes. One unlock costs 3 credits and covers this episode forever: full segment and word-level timestamps on this page, plus .txt, .srt, .vtt and word-level JSON downloads, as many times as you like.